Red Badge
(Battleground, 1949)
Watching a war movie
One of the better in
The genre
Everyone is frightened
Winter doesn’t help
Low clouds by day, and
There’s confusion
Even though
There’s order, too
How could I survive?
With my heart, I couldn’t
If it is congenital
(which is the current
guess), I guess I never
Could
Have gone
I’d miss the songs
The whistling in the dark
The weather that
Never seems to serve
Privation be it food
Or something potable
(who doesn’t need
a drink when drafted
at eighteen?),
Ammunition or the distance
That a letter brings,
A photograph
I’m speaking of the past
(the movie’s reach)
Now there are screens
And firm tries at
Armor, stronger missiles
That can guide
Themselves, it seems
Still, it’s a hellish business
No one should make
Money from it, then
Or now—It should be
A charity, the kind
That Lincoln said
We should have toward
All, funded through our
Tax dollars, as they
Say, at work this time
As a 501c3
Bring everyone back
In that fine order,
When it’s done. so
We all might start
Over, over here
It’s Sunday, and
I’m thinking about bullets
The kind that tear
Into flesh and
Malice in randomness
Through windows,
Let alone the shells,
As has been shown
While what
Is heard
Is a civilian scream
From the dark
Inside
Outside the street
Is burning, around
The pyres a dog
Alone, dodging
War tears into streets
There will never
Be another neighborhood
For good
This was my Sunday
Morning, sorry
I was not in church
But here—there was
A church scene in the
Movie, a chaplain
With a foot-wrapped
Message (first message
that of having given
boots away to another
soldier in that charity,
remember?)
That the Nazis wanted
War (they did want,
as remnants today)
So we, everyone
Who could—Pole,
Italian, Asian, Irish,
Latin, Black, Harvard,
Brooklyn—had
Some saving to do
Pastors, always
Talking about saving
I wish I could feel
Better but don’t
I’m tired, and I should
Have been at church
I should be
A better neighbor,
Standing up for what
Is right more often
Not merely
Trust a system
Here there were
Ranks and also branches
Stuffed in foxholes
With soldiers sharing
Cigarettes and stories
Chewing on
K rations unthankfully
(and why?)
Wanting chocolate and
The Stars and Stripes
To tell them beyond
The shoulders of
The next one
That war was
Over, peace declared,
And all go home
Maybe to another
Generation lost
But home it is
C L Couch
Photo by Kony Xyzx on Unsplash
February 9, 2020 at 5:47 pm
So hard to criticise war. You’re told you’re besmirching the memory of the heroes who sacrificed their lives for us, so we could have all this etc etc. Yet the heroes would probably be the first to say, if only we’d been allowed to choose what to fight for/against or to stay at home.
February 9, 2020 at 6:44 pm
I think soldiers–and I’ve talked with many by now or heard or read their comments–would not doubt the good causes, when causes were good, but would have chosen another way, if only the world allowed.
You’re right, hard to demonize. And beyond affirming the lunacy of war, I don’t want to, not the ordinary combatants, certainly.
February 9, 2020 at 7:42 pm
No, they do what they’re told. The conscripts anyway. The others, the ones who do it for a living, I’m not so sure about. We see so many atrocities committed by soldiers on their own people. Men shouldn’t be given guns unless there is absolutely no other way of defending their country/loved ones.
February 10, 2020 at 3:20 am
Yes, I’ve been thinking of this ever since I sent the word “combatants” (above), though my concern was demonizing. Most of the soldiers (ex-) I know put in their time (drafted or enlisted for a hitch or maybe put in what is called the “twenty”), then retired. I might not know any career soldiers. And I don’t know anyone who thinks war is a good idea, soldiers and the rest.
Atrocities of war. Yes, soldiers on the, uh, good side (whatever that is), too, can commit these. It’s probably not reasonable to think that all groups with people in them might have criminals. War is violent and lunatic and brings out the violent and lunatic in those prone to these dangers and maybe in anyone. An end to war wouldn’t solve all the problems but would do something, certainly.
You’re so right that guns should be a last recourse for fighting as defending. It would be wonderful and an unimaginable relief if we knew there were far fewer guns at hand than there are now.